,668('ꢀꢁꢁꢁꢁ0$<ꢁꢁꢁꢁꢂꢃꢁꢄꢅꢅꢂ
5(9,6('ꢀꢁꢁ'(&ꢆꢁꢂꢇꢃꢁꢄꢅꢅꢇ
+26+,=$.,
&2817(5ꢀ6+2:&$6(
02'(/ +1&ꢁꢂꢃ$$ꢁ/ꢄ5
+1&ꢁꢅꢆꢃ$$ꢁ/ꢄ5
+1&ꢁꢅꢇꢃ$$ꢁ/ꢄ5
+1&ꢁꢅꢈꢃ$$ꢁ/ꢄ5
+1&ꢁꢆꢅꢃ$$ꢁ/ꢄ5
,16758&7,21ꢀ0$18$/
,03257$17
ꢂꢆꢁ7KLVꢁERRNOHWꢁLVꢁDQꢁLQWHJUDOꢁDQGꢁHVVHQWLDOꢁSDUWꢁRIꢁWKHꢁSURGXFWꢁDQGꢁVKRXOGꢁEH
KDQGHGꢁRYHUꢁWRꢁWKHꢁXVHUꢆꢁꢁ5HDGꢁWKHꢁZDUQLQJVꢁFRQWDLQHGꢁLQꢁWKLVꢁERRNOHWꢁFDUHIXOO\
DVꢁWKH\ꢁJLYHꢁLPSRUWDQWꢁLQGLFDWLRQVꢁUHJDUGLQJꢁWKHꢁVDIHW\ꢁRIꢁWKHꢁLQVWDOODWLRQꢃꢁXVH
DQGꢁPDLQWHQDQFHꢆꢁꢁ3OHDVHꢁSUHVHUYHꢁWKLVꢁERRNOHWꢁIRUꢁDQ\ꢁIXUWKHUꢁFRQVXOWDWLRQ
WKDWꢁPD\ꢁEHꢁQHFHVVDU\ꢆ
ꢄꢆꢁ7KLVꢁLVꢁDꢁFRPPHUFLDOꢁVKRZFDVHꢁDQGꢁVKRXOGꢁEHꢁGHVWLQHGꢁRQO\ꢁWRꢁWKHꢁXVHꢁIRU
ZKLFKꢁLWꢁKDVꢁEHHQꢁH[SUHVVO\ꢁFRQFHLYHGꢆꢁꢁ$Q\ꢁRWKHUꢁXVHꢁVKRXOGꢁEHꢁFRQVLGHUHG
LPSURSHUꢁDQGꢁWKHUHIRUHꢁGDQJHURXVꢆꢁꢁ7KHꢁPDQXIDFWXUHUꢁFDQQRWꢁEHꢁKHOG
UHVSRQVLEOHꢁIRUꢁHYHQWXDOꢁGDPDJHꢁFDXVHGꢁE\ꢁLPSURSHUꢃꢁLQFRUUHFWꢁDQG
XQUHDVRQDEOHꢁXVHꢆ
&217(176
3$*(
,ꢆꢁ*(1(5$/ꢁ,1)250$7,21 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢂ
ꢂꢆꢁ&216758&7,21 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢂ
,,ꢆꢁ,167$//$7,21ꢁ$1'ꢁ23(5$7,1*ꢁ,16758&7,216ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢄ
ꢂꢆꢁ&+(&.6ꢁ%()25(ꢁ,167$//$7,21ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢄ
ꢄꢆꢁ/2&$7,21ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢄ
ꢌꢆꢁ6(7ꢁ83ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢌ
ꢋꢆꢁ(/(&75,&$/ꢁ&211(&7,216ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢋ
ꢇꢆꢁ'5$,1ꢁ&211(&7,216 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢋ
ꢈꢆꢁ),1$/ꢁ&+(&.ꢁ/,67 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢇ
ꢊꢆꢁ67$57ꢁ83 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢈ
,,,ꢆꢁ0$,17(1$1&(ꢁ$1'ꢁ&/($1,1*ꢁ,16758&7,216 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢉ
ꢂꢆꢁ,17(5,25ꢑ(;7(5,25 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢉ
ꢄꢆꢁ'5$,1ꢁ3,3(ꢁ&/($1,1* ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢉ
ꢌꢆꢁ$,5ꢁ),/7(5 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢍ
ꢋꢆꢁ&21'(16(5 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢍ
ꢇꢆꢁ&+(&.,1*ꢁ*5281'ꢁ)$8/7ꢁ,17(55837(5 ꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎꢎ ꢍ
,ꢂꢀ*(1(5$/ꢀ,1)250$7,21
ꢃꢂꢀ&216758&7,21
1DPHSODWH
ꢁꢁꢁꢁ-RLQW
ꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁ+RVH
ꢁ3OXJꢒ
&RQG
$LUꢁ)
ꢁꢁꢁꢁ6OLGLQJꢁ*ODVVꢁ'RRU
ꢁꢁꢁꢁ)RRGꢁ0RXQW
ꢒ1RWHꢀꢁ$OZD\VꢁDWWDFKꢁWKHꢁ3OXJꢏVꢐꢁWRꢁWKHꢁGUDLQꢁKROHVꢁORFDWHGꢁLQꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢆ
)LJꢂꢀꢃ
ꢂ
,,ꢂꢀ,167$//$7,21ꢀ$1'ꢀ23(5$7,1*ꢀ,16758&7,216
ꢃꢂꢀ&+(&.6ꢀ%()25(ꢀ,167$//$7,21
ꢒꢁ9LVXDOO\ꢁLQVSHFWꢁWKHꢁH[WHULRUꢁRIꢁWKHꢁVKLSSLQJꢁFRQWDLQHUꢃꢁDQGꢁDQ\ꢁVHYHUHꢁGDPDJHꢁQRWHGꢁVKRXOG
EHꢁUHSRUWHGꢁWRꢁWKHꢁFDUULHUꢆ
:$51,1*
5HPRYHꢁVKLSSLQJꢁFDUWRQꢃꢁHYDSRUDWRUꢁVSDFHUꢃꢁWDSHꢏVꢐꢁDQGꢁSDFNLQJꢆꢁꢁ,IꢁSDFNLQJ
PDWHULDOꢁLVꢁOHIWꢁLQꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢃꢁLWꢁZLOOꢁQRWꢁZRUNꢁSURSHUO\ꢆ
,03257$17
5HPRYHꢁVKLSSLQJꢁWDSHꢁKROGLQJꢁWKHꢁ'RRUꢆ
ꢒꢁ5HPRYHꢁWKHꢁSDFNDJHꢁFRQWDLQLQJꢁDFFHVVRULHVꢆ
ꢒꢁ6HHꢁWKHꢁ1DPHSODWHꢁRQꢁWKHꢁUHDUꢁRIꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢃꢁDQGꢁFKHFNꢁWKDWꢁ\RXUꢁYROWDJHꢁVXSSOLHG
FRUUHVSRQGVꢁZLWKꢁWKHꢁYROWDJHꢁVSHFLILHGꢁRQꢁWKHꢁ1DPHSODWHꢆ
ꢄꢂꢀ/2&$7,21
:$51,1*
7KLVꢁVKRZFDVHꢁLVꢁQRWꢁLQWHQGHGꢁIRUꢁRXWGRRUꢁXVHꢆꢁꢁ1RUPDOꢁRSHUDWLQJꢁDPELHQW
WHPSHUDWXUHꢁVKRXOGꢁEHꢁZLWKLQꢁꢇꢅƒ)ꢁꢏꢂꢅƒ&ꢐꢁWRꢁꢉꢅƒ)ꢁꢏꢄꢊƒ&ꢐꢆꢁꢁ2SHUDWLRQꢁRIꢁWKH
VKRZFDVHꢃꢁIRUꢁH[WHQGHGꢁSHULRGVꢃꢁRXWVLGHꢁRIꢁWKLVꢁQRUPDOꢁWHPSHUDWXUHꢁUDQJHꢁPD\
DIIHFWꢁFRROLQJꢁSHUIRUPDQFHꢆ
)RUꢁEHVWꢁRSHUDWLQJꢁUHVXOWVꢀ
ꢒꢁ7KHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁVKRXOGꢁQRWꢁEHꢁORFDWHGꢁQH[WꢁWRꢁRYHQVꢃꢁJULOOVꢁRUꢁRWKHUꢁKLJKꢁKHDWꢁSURGXFLQJ
HTXLSPHQWꢆ
ꢒꢁ7KHꢁORFDWLRQꢁVKRXOGꢁSURYLGHꢁDꢁILUPꢁIRXQGDWLRQ
IRUꢁWKHꢁHTXLSPHQWꢁZKHUHꢁLWVꢁHQWLUHꢁERWWRP
VXUIDFHꢁFDQꢁEHꢁVWHDGLO\ꢁSRVLWLRQHGꢆꢁꢁ/HYHO
WKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁIURPꢁVLGHꢁWRꢁVLGHꢁDQGꢁIURQWꢁWR
UHDUꢆꢁꢁ,QVWDOODWLRQꢁRIꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁRQO\ꢁSDUWO\
LQꢁFRQWDFWꢁZLWKꢁWKHꢁIRXQGDWLRQꢁPD\ꢁUHVXOWꢁLQ
GHIRUPDWLRQꢃꢁGDPDJHꢁRUꢁIDLOXUHꢆ
1RꢁJRRG
ꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁ*RRG
)LJꢂꢀꢄ
ꢄ
1RꢁJRRG
ꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁ*RRG
,IꢁWKHꢁIRXQGDWLRQꢁLVꢁQRWꢁILUPꢁHQRXJKꢃꢁLWꢁPD\
ZDUSꢁDQGꢁFDXVHꢁVRPHꢁVSDFHꢁEHWZHHQꢁLWV
FHQWHUꢁDQGꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁERWWRPꢆꢁꢁ,QꢁWKLV
FDVHꢃꢁ SURYLGHꢁ Dꢁ VXSSRUWꢁ WRꢁ NHHSꢁ WKH
IRXQGDWLRQꢁOHYHOꢆ
6XSSRUW
)LJꢂꢀꢆ
ꢒꢁ$YRLGꢁDꢁVLWHꢁZKHUHꢁGULSSLQJꢁLVꢁQRWꢁDOORZHGꢆ
ꢒꢁ'RꢁQRWꢁH[SRVHꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁWRꢁGLUHFWꢁVXQOLJKWꢁRUꢁKLJKHUꢁWHPSHUDWXUHVꢁWRꢁSUHYHQWꢁGDPDJHꢁWR
WKHꢁSODVWLFꢁKRXVLQJꢆ
ꢒꢁ$OORZꢁDWꢁOHDVWꢁꢈ´ꢁꢏꢂꢇFPꢐꢁFOHDUDQFHꢁEHWZHHQꢁWKHꢁ&RQGHQVHUꢁDLUꢁLQOHWꢑRXWOHWꢁDQGꢁWKHꢁZDOOꢁRU
RWKHUꢁHTXLSPHQWꢁIRUꢁSURSHUꢁDLUꢁFLUFXODWLRQꢆꢁꢁ7KHꢁUHDUꢁRIꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁVKRXOGꢁKDYHꢁHQRXJK
VSDFHꢁIRUꢁVPRRWKꢁRSHUDWLRQꢁRIꢁWKHꢁ3RZHUꢁ6ZLWFKꢁDQGꢁIRUꢁHDV\ꢁDFFHVVꢁWRꢁWKHꢁ/RXYHUꢁDQGꢁ$LU
)LOWHUꢆ
$LUꢁ,QOHW
$LUꢁ2XWOHW
ꢈ´
ꢁꢁꢁꢁꢈ´
)LJꢂꢀꢅ
ꢆꢂꢀ6(7ꢀ83
,03257$17
&DUU\ꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁE\ꢁKROGLQJꢁLWVꢁERWWRPꢆ
ꢂꢐꢁ8QSDFNꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢃꢁDQGꢁUHPRYHꢁDOOꢁVKLSSLQJꢁFDUWRQꢃꢁHYDSRUDWRUꢁVSDFHUꢃꢁWDSHVꢁDQG
SDFNLQJꢁ%()25(ꢁRSHUDWLQJꢁWKHꢁXQLWꢆꢁꢁ%HꢁFDUHIXOꢁQRWꢁWRꢁGDPDJHꢁWKHꢁH[WHULRUꢁSDQHOVꢁZKHQ
KDQGOLQJꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢆ
ꢌ
ꢄꢐꢁ3RVLWLRQꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁLQꢁDꢁVHOHFWHGꢁVLWHꢆꢁꢁ&OHDQꢁWKHꢁLQWHULRUꢁZLWKꢁVRDSꢁDQGꢁZDWHUꢁDQG
ULQVHꢁWKRURXJKO\ꢆ
ꢌꢐꢁ/HYHOꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁLQꢁERWKꢁWKHꢁOHIWꢎWRꢎULJKWꢁDQGꢁWKHꢁIURQWꢎWRꢎUHDUꢁGLUHFWLRQVꢆ
ꢋꢐꢁ7KHꢁSHULPHWHUꢁZKHUHꢁWKHꢁPDFKLQHꢁWRXFKHVꢁWKHꢁFRXQWHUꢁVKRXOGꢁEHꢁVHDOHGꢁZLWKꢁVLOLFRQHꢆ
ꢅꢂꢀ(/(&75,&$/ꢀ&211(&7,216
ꢒꢁ7KLVꢁVKRZFDVHꢁPXVWꢁEHꢁSOXJJHGꢁLQWRꢁWKHꢁVHSDUDWHGꢁSRZHUꢁUHFHSWDFOHꢁZKLFKꢁKDVꢁHQRXJK
FDSDFLW\ꢆꢁ7KHꢁPD[LPXPꢁDOORZDEOHꢁYROWDJHꢁYDULDWLRQꢁVKRXOGꢁQRWꢁH[FHHGꢁ“ꢁꢂꢅꢁSHUFHQWꢁRIꢁWKH
QDPHSODWHꢁUDWLQJꢆꢁꢁ6HHꢁWKHꢁ1DPHSODWHꢆ
ꢇꢂꢀ'5$,1ꢀ&211(&7,216
ꢒꢁ7KHꢁ+RVHꢁPD\ꢁEHꢁFRQQHFWHGꢁWRꢁHLWKHUꢁULJKWꢁRUꢁOHIWꢁMRLQWꢃꢁZKLFKHYHUꢁLVꢁFRQYHQLHQWꢆ
ꢒꢁ.HHSꢁPRUHꢁWKDQꢁꢄꢁYHUWLFDOꢁLQFKꢁꢏꢇꢁYHUWLFDOꢁFPꢐꢁDLUꢁJDSꢁEHWZHHQꢁWKHꢁGUDLQꢁSLSHꢁHQGꢁDQGꢁWKH
VLQNꢆ
ꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁ+RVH
QꢁRUꢁVLQN
ꢋ
ꢈꢂꢀ),1$/ꢀ&+(&.ꢀ/,67
ꢂꢐꢁ,VꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁOHYHO"
ꢄꢐꢁ,VꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁLQꢁDꢁVLWHꢁZKHUHꢁWKHꢁDPELHQWꢁWHPSHUDWXUHꢁLVꢁZLWKLQꢁꢇꢅƒ)ꢁꢏꢂꢅƒ&ꢐꢁWRꢁꢉꢅƒ)
ꢏꢄꢊƒ&ꢐꢁDOOꢁ\HDUꢁDURXQG"
ꢌꢐꢁ+DYHꢁDOOꢁVKLSSLQJꢁFDUWRQꢃꢁHYDSRUDWRUꢁVSDFHUꢃꢁWDSHꢏVꢐꢁDQGꢁSDFNLQJꢁEHHQꢁUHPRYHGꢁIURPꢁWKH
VKRZFDVH"
ꢋꢐꢁ+DYHꢁDOOꢁHOHFWULFDOꢁDQGꢁSLSLQJꢁFRQQHFWLRQVꢁEHHQꢁPDGH"
ꢇꢐꢁ+DVꢁWKHꢁSRZHUꢁVXSSO\ꢁYROWDJHꢁEHHQꢁWHVWHGꢁRUꢁFKHFNHGꢁDJDLQVWꢁWKHꢁQDPHSODWHꢁUDWLQJ"
ꢈꢐꢁ+DVꢁWKHꢁXVHUꢁEHHQꢁJLYHQꢁWKHꢁ,QVWUXFWLRQꢁ0DQXDOꢁDQGꢁLQVWUXFWHGꢁRQꢁKRZꢁWRꢁRSHUDWHꢁWKH
VKRZFDVHꢁDQGꢁWKHꢁLPSRUWDQFHꢁRIꢁSHULRGLFꢁPDLQWHQDQFHꢁUHFRPPHQGHG"
ꢊꢐꢁ+DVꢁWKHꢁXVHUꢁEHHQꢁJLYHQꢁWKHꢁQDPHꢁDQGꢁWHOHSKRQHꢁQXPEHUꢁRIꢁWKHꢁ$XWKRUL]HGꢁ6HUYLFH
$JHQF\"
ꢇ
ꢉꢂꢀ67$57ꢀ83
,03257$17
ꢂꢆꢁ%HꢁFDUHIXOꢁQRWꢁWRꢁOHWꢁZDWHUꢁLQWRꢁWKHꢁPDFKLQHꢁFRPSDUWPHQWꢁDQGꢁRYHUꢁWKHꢁH[WHULRUꢆ
7KLVꢁPLJKWꢁFDXVHꢁDQꢁHOHFWULFꢁVKRFNꢁKD]DUGꢆ
ꢄꢆꢁ'RꢁQRWꢁSOXJꢁLQꢁDQGꢁXQSOXJꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁIUHTXHQWO\ꢆꢁꢁ7KLVꢁPD\ꢁUHVXOWꢁLQꢁIDLOXUH
RUꢁVKRUWHUꢁVHUYLFHꢁOLIHꢆ
ꢌꢆꢁ%HꢁVXUHꢁWRꢁSUHFKLOOꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁEHIRUHꢁSXWWLQJꢁIRRGVꢁLQꢆꢁꢁ6WRUHꢁRQO\ꢁSUHꢎ
UHIULJHUDWHGꢁLWHPVꢁLQꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢆꢁꢁ,WꢁWDNHVꢁORQJHUꢁIRUꢁIRRGVꢁWRꢁFRROꢁLQꢁWKH
VKRZFDVHꢁWKDQꢁLQꢁDꢁUHIULJHUDWRUꢆꢁꢁ$IWHUꢁVHUYLFHꢁKRXUVꢃꢁPRYHꢁIRRGVꢁLQWRꢁD
UHIULJHUDWRUꢆ
ꢋꢆꢁ'RꢁQRWꢁOHDYHꢁWKHꢁ'RRUVꢁRSHQꢁRUꢁRSHQꢁWKHPꢁWRRꢁIUHTXHQWO\ꢆꢁꢁ7KHꢁLQWHULRU
WHPSHUDWXUHꢁPD\ꢁULVHꢃꢁUHVXOWLQJꢁLQꢁIRRGꢁGHWHULRUDWLRQꢆ
ꢇꢆꢁ7RꢁXQSOXJꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁIRUꢁGHIURVWLQJꢃꢁILUVWꢁUHPRYHꢁWKHꢁLWHPVꢁLQVLGHꢁWRꢁSURWHFW
WKHPꢁIURPꢁGURSVꢁRIꢁGHIURVWꢁZDWHUꢆ
ꢈꢆꢁ,WꢁLVꢁQRUPDOꢁWRꢁILQGꢁFRQGHQVDWLRQꢁRQꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁLQꢁDꢁKXPLGꢁRUꢁUDLQ\ꢁZHDWKHUꢆ
6LPSO\ꢁZLSHꢁLWꢁRIIꢁZLWKꢁDꢁVRIWꢁFORWKꢁIURPꢁWLPHꢁWRꢁWLPHꢆ
ꢊꢆꢁ&RQWUROꢁWKHꢁIRRGꢁWHPSHUDWXUHꢁE\ꢁSODFLQJꢁWKHꢁ)RRGꢁ0RXQWVꢁDVꢁIROORZVꢀ
1RUPDOꢁFRQGLWLRQ
:KHQꢁIRRGꢁWHPSꢆꢁLVꢁWRRꢁORZ
)RUꢁPRUHꢁLQWHQVLYHꢁFRROLQJ
ꢉꢆꢁ7KHꢁPD[LPXPꢁVDIHꢁKHLJKWꢁIRUꢁGLVSOD\LQJꢁIRRGꢁSURGXFWVꢁLVꢁꢌꢆꢇ´ꢁꢏꢍFPꢐꢁDERYH
WKHꢁLQWHULRUꢁERWWRPꢆꢁꢁ)RRGꢁSURGXFWVꢁVKRXOGꢁQRWꢁEHꢁSODFHGꢁDERYHꢁWKLVꢁKHLJKWꢁDV
WKH\ꢁPD\ꢁQRWꢁUHPDLQꢁFROGꢁHQRXJKꢁWRꢁDYRLGꢁVSRLODJHꢆ
ꢍꢆꢁ,IꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁLVꢁWXUQHGꢁRIIꢃꢁZDLWꢁIRUꢁDWꢁOHDVWꢁꢌꢁPLQXWHVꢁEHIRUHꢁUHVWDUWLQJꢁWKH
VKRZFDVHꢆꢁꢁ2WKHUZLVHꢁWKHꢁRYHUORDGꢁSURWHFWRUꢁPD\ꢁRSHUDWHꢁDQGꢁDOORZꢁGHIURVW
ZDWHUꢁWRꢁGULSꢁRQWRꢁWKHꢁLWHPVꢁLQVLGHꢆꢁꢁ7KHꢁRYHUORDGꢁSURWHFWRUꢁZLOOꢁUHVHW
DXWRPDWLFDOO\ꢁLQꢁꢌꢅꢁPLQXWHVꢆ
ꢂꢅꢆꢁ7RꢁSUHYHQWꢁGDPDJHꢁWRꢁWKHꢁJODVVꢁSDUWVꢃꢁGR
QRWꢁSODFHꢁRUꢁKLWꢁDQ\ꢁWDEOHZDUHꢃꢁERWWOHVꢁRU
HGJHGꢁWRROVꢁGLUHFWO\ꢁRQꢁWKHꢁJODVVꢁVXUIDFHVꢆ
(YHQꢁDꢁWLQ\ꢁIODZꢁPD\ꢁJURZꢁLQWRꢁDꢁFUDFNꢁꢏD
IHZꢁGD\VꢐꢁODWHUꢆ
ꢈ
ꢂꢂꢆꢁ7RꢁDYRLGꢁHQWUDQFHꢁRIꢁYHUPLQꢃꢁWKHꢁGUDLQ
RXWOHWꢏVꢐꢁRQꢁWKHꢁULJKWꢁDQGꢑRUꢁOHIWꢁXQGHUꢁWKH
)RRGꢁ0RXQWVꢁPXVWꢁDOZD\VꢁEHꢁILOOHGꢁZLWKꢁWKH
3OXJꢏVꢐꢁSURYLGHGꢆ
ꢂꢐꢁ&OHDQꢁLQVLGHꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢆ
ꢄꢐꢁ3OXJꢁLQꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢃꢁDQGꢁWXUQꢁRQꢁWKHꢁ3RZHUꢁ6ZLWFKꢆ
ꢒꢁ:KHQꢁQRWꢁLQꢁXVHꢃꢁGU\ꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁWKRURXJKO\ꢁDQGꢁVWRUHꢁLWꢁLQꢁDꢁGU\ꢁSODFHꢆ
ꢊ
,,,ꢂꢀ0$,17(1$1&(ꢀ$1'ꢀ&/($1,1*ꢀ,16758&7,216
,03257$17
ꢂꢆꢁ%HIRUHꢁFDUU\LQJꢁRXWꢁDQ\ꢁFOHDQLQJꢁRUꢁPDLQWHQDQFHꢁRSHUDWLRQVꢃꢁXQSOXJꢁWKH
VKRZFDVHꢆ
ꢄꢆꢁ'RꢁQRWꢁGLVDVVHPEOHꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢁIXUWKHUꢁWKDQꢁLOOXVWUDWHGꢁLQꢁ)LJꢆꢁꢂꢆ
ꢌꢆꢁ'RꢁQRWꢁWRXFKꢁRUꢁZHWꢁWKHꢁPDFKLQHꢁFRPSDUWPHQWꢁSDUWVꢆꢁꢁ7KLVꢁFRXOGꢁUHVXOWꢁLQ
IDLOXUHꢁRUꢁEUHDNGRZQꢆ
ꢃꢂꢀ,17(5,25ꢊ(;7(5,25
ꢒꢁ&OHDQꢁWKHꢁLQWHULRUꢁDQGꢁ)RRGꢁ0RXQWVꢁHYHU\ꢁGD\ꢁIRUꢁVDQLWDU\ꢁXVHꢆ
ꢒꢁ8VHꢁDꢁVRIWꢁFORWKꢁVRDNHGꢁLQꢁZDUPꢁZDWHUꢁWRꢁFOHDQꢁRIIꢁWKHꢁH[WHULRUꢆꢁꢁ'RꢁQRWꢁXVHꢁDꢁZDWHUꢁMHWꢁWR
FOHDQꢁWKHꢁH[WHULRUꢆ
ꢒꢁ8VHꢁRQO\ꢁDꢁQHXWUDOꢁFOHDQHUꢆꢁꢁ2WKHUꢁFKHPLFDOꢁDJHQWVꢁPLJKWꢁFDXVHꢁGDPDJHꢁWRꢁWKHꢁLQWHULRUꢁDQG
H[WHULRUꢁVXUIDFHVꢆ
1RWHꢀ 7RꢁSUHYHQWꢁGDPDJHꢁWRꢁWKHꢁSDUWꢁVXUIDFHVꢁDQGꢁWKHꢁSODWLQJꢁRQꢁWKHꢁ(YDSRUDWRUꢃꢁGRꢁQRWꢁXVH
DꢁVFRXUHUꢁRQꢁWKHꢁLQWHULRUꢑH[WHULRUꢁVXUIDFHVꢆ
ꢄꢂꢀ'5$,1ꢀ3,3(ꢀ&/($1,1*
ꢂꢐ (LWKHUꢁPL[ꢁꢅꢆꢄꢈꢁJDOꢆꢁꢏꢂꢁOLWHUꢐꢁRIꢁZDWHUꢁZLWKꢁꢅꢆꢂꢌꢁIOꢆꢁR]ꢆꢁꢏꢌꢆꢊꢁPOꢐꢁRIꢁꢇꢆꢄꢇꢓꢁVRGLXPꢁK\SRFKORULWH
VROXWLRQꢁLQꢁDꢁVXLWDEOHꢁFRQWDLQHUꢃꢁRUꢁWKHꢁUHFRPPHQGHGꢁ+RVKL]DNLꢁVDQLWL]HUꢁDVꢁGLUHFWHGꢆ
ꢄꢐ 'LVFRQQHFWꢁWKHꢁ+RVHꢁIURPꢁWKHꢁ-RLQWꢆ
ꢌꢐ 7XUQꢁXSꢁWKHꢁHQGꢁRIꢁWKHꢁ-RLQWꢏVꢐꢆ
ꢋꢐ 6ORZO\ꢁSRXUꢁWKHꢁVDQLWL]LQJꢁVROXWLRQꢁLQWRꢁWKHꢁGUDLQꢁZDWHUꢁFLUFXLWꢁIURPꢁWKHꢁ-RLQWꢏVꢐꢆ
ꢇꢐ :DLWꢁIRUꢁꢇꢁPLQXWHVꢃꢁDQGꢁWXUQꢁGRZQꢁWKHꢁHQGꢁRIꢁWKHꢁ-RLQWꢏVꢐꢁWRꢁGUDLQꢁWKHꢁVROXWLRQꢆ
ꢈꢐ /HDYHꢁWKHꢁGUDLQꢁZDWHUꢁFLUFXLWꢁWRꢁGU\ꢁRXWꢆ
ꢉ
ꢆꢂꢀ$,5ꢀ),/7(5
$ꢁSODVWLFꢁPHVKꢁDLUꢁILOWHUꢁUHPRYHVꢁGLUWꢁRUꢁGXVWꢁIURPꢁWKHꢁDLUꢃꢁDQGꢁNHHSVꢁWKHꢁ&RQGHQVHUꢁIURP
JHWWLQJꢁFORJJHGꢆꢁꢁ$VꢁWKHꢁILOWHUꢁJHWVꢁFORJJHGꢃꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVH¶VꢁSHUIRUPDQFHꢁZLOOꢁEHꢁUHGXFHGꢆ
&KHFNꢁWKHꢁILOWHUꢁDWꢁOHDVWꢁWZLFHꢁDꢁPRQWKꢆꢁꢁ:KHQꢁFORJJHGꢃꢁXVHꢁZDUPꢁZDWHUꢁDQGꢁDꢁQHXWUDOꢁFOHDQHU
WRꢁZDVKꢁWKHꢁILOWHUꢆ
ꢂꢐꢁ+ROGꢁWKHꢁWDEVꢁORFDWHGꢁDWꢁWKHꢁERWWRPꢁRIꢁWKHꢁ/RXYHUꢃꢁDQGꢁOLIWꢁWKHPꢁXSꢁWRꢁUHOHDVHꢁWKHꢁ/RXYHU
IURPꢁWKHꢁERG\ꢆ
ꢄꢐꢁ3XOOꢁWKHꢁ/RXYHUꢁWRZDUGꢁ\RXꢆ
ꢌꢐꢁ3XOOꢁRXWꢁWKHꢁ/RXYHUꢁGRZQZDUGꢆ
ꢋꢐꢁ3LFNꢁWKHꢁIUDPHꢁRIꢁWKHꢁ$LUꢁ)LOWHUꢃꢁDQGꢁSXOOꢁLWꢁRXWꢁWRZDUGꢁ\RXꢆ
ꢇꢐꢁ&OHDQꢁWKHꢁ$LUꢁ)LOWHUꢆ
ꢈꢐꢁ5HILWꢁWKHꢁ$LUꢁ)LOWHUꢁDQGꢁ/RXYHUꢁLQꢁWKHꢁUHYHUVHꢁRUGHUꢁRIꢁWKHꢁUHPRYDOꢁSURFHGXUHꢆ
)LJꢂꢀꢈ
ꢅꢂꢀ&21'(16(5
&KHFNꢁWKHꢁ&RQGHQVHUꢁRQFHꢁDꢁ\HDUꢃꢁDQGꢁFOHDQꢁLIꢁUHTXLUHGꢁE\ꢁXVLQJꢁDꢁEUXVKꢁRUꢁYDFXXPꢁFOHDQHUꢆ
0RUHꢁIUHTXHQWꢁFOHDQLQJꢁPD\ꢁEHꢁUHTXLUHGꢁGHSHQGLQJꢁRQꢁWKHꢁORFDWLRQꢁRIꢁWKHꢁVKRZFDVHꢆ
ꢇꢂꢀ&+(&.,1*ꢀ*5281'ꢀ)$8/7ꢀ,17(55837(5
3XVKꢁWKHꢁWHVWꢁEXWWRQꢁDWꢁOHDVWꢁRQFHꢁDꢁPRQWKꢃꢁDQGꢁVLPXODWHꢁDꢁJURXQGꢁIDXOWꢁRQꢁWKHꢁORDGꢁFLUFXLWꢆ
ꢍ
+26+,=$.,ꢀ$0(5,&$ꢋꢀ,1&ꢂ
ꢈꢃꢏꢀ+,*+:$<ꢀꢉꢅꢀ6287+
3($&+75((ꢀ&,7<ꢋꢀ*$ꢀꢆꢍꢄꢈꢎ
8ꢂ6ꢂ$ꢂ
3+21(ꢁꢀꢉꢉꢍꢌꢅꢏꢉꢌꢄꢆꢆꢃ
ZZZꢂKRVKL]DNLDPHULFDꢂFRP
+26+,=$.,ꢀ(/(&75,&ꢀ&2ꢂꢋꢀ/7'ꢂ
ꢆꢌꢃꢈꢀ0,1$0,<$.$7$ꢋꢀ6$.$(ꢋꢀ72<2$.(ꢋ
$,&+,ꢀꢅꢉꢍꢌꢃꢃꢎꢅꢀ-$3$1
3+21(ꢁꢀꢍꢇꢈꢄꢌꢎꢉꢌꢄꢃꢃꢃ
ꢍꢂꢊꢋ1$ꢂꢅ%
|